The Importance of Education
That’s a very good question. I’d say for those of us that eat meat, its ok to raise an animal for food when the conditions are humane and the animal has what it needs in its living space to be comfortable and healthy. Perhaps a more important question is, how do we know and best provide what they need?
What people need is educational resources. This applies not only to raising animals but to growing food in general. The public needs to know how to test soil, how to remediate soil, how to use soil amendments like manure without contamination, how to control pests without use of toxic pesticides. There will always be the case of ignorant choices made. However defining the best way to do something and educating folks on it is a great way to reduce, even eliminate, these cases.
Luckily Oakland has an abundance of willing people and resources to address this. Luckily, there are many large national cities that have made it legal to raise your own animals for food. These cities provide successful examples.
Where I cannot follow in this article is how the very valid concern for animal welfare gets interwoven into the debate about whether it is ok to eat meat. An advocate that believes rabbits are strictly companion animals says that they are companions in “our society.” This is not true at all. They are strictly companions in her culture, but not in many others. The U.S. is made up of many cultures, not any one. Also, those cities that have made raising animals for food legal allow rabbits. So, they must not have gotten that memo about “our society.” Oakland is proud of its diverse cultural heritages, which include food traditions. I hope they continue to preserve this unique aspect of the city.
This “our society” sentiment coupled with the belief that that gang violence can be mitigated if we all just stop eating meat, speaks volumes of the narrow cultural demographic of these advocates. It is extreme and unreasonable to expect people to give up their cultural practices and conform to such narrow beliefs. I am tired of this attitude that we need to shed our traditions to be righteous.








